Agenda, decisions and minutes

Planning Committee - Wednesday, 14th July, 2021 7.00 pm

Venue: Council Chamber

Contact: Committee Services 

Items
No. Item

20.

MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING pdf icon PDF 184 KB

The Minutes of the meeting held on 9 June 2021 to be confirmed and signed as a correct record.

Minutes:

The Minutes of the meeting held on 9 June 2021?were?confirmed and signed as a correct record.

21.

APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE

To receive any apologies for absence from Members*.

 

*Note: Members are asked to email Committee Services in advance of the meeting as soon as they become aware they will be absent.

Minutes:

None received.

22.

DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST

To declare disclosable pecuniary, and any other, interests*.

 

*Note: Members are asked to email Committee Services in advance of the meeting as soon as they become aware they may have an interest to declare.

Minutes:

Councillor Quarterman declared an interest in Item 7 (20/02368/AMCON- Land Between Moulsham Lane And Broome Close Yateley) due to proximity to his property and so would withdraw.

 

23.

CHAIRMAN'S ANNOUNCEMENTS

Minutes:

Councillor Oliver to organise a date in September for the Planning Committee Working Group.

24.

DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS pdf icon PDF 246 KB

To consider the planning reports from the Head of Place, and to accept updates via the Addendum.

Minutes:

Members accepted updates via the Addendum and considered the planning report from the Head of Place.

25.

21/00403/FUL - 8 CROWNFIELDS, ODIHAM pdf icon PDF 1 MB

Decision:

Construction of a three-bedroom dwelling with associated car parking and hard/soft landscaping.

 

DECISION - GRANTas per Officer recommendation with a change to condition 2 to include sustainability measures as detailed in the correspondence with the applicant and the addition of two Informatives.

 

CONDITIONS

 

1. The development hereby permitted shall be begun before the expiration of three years from the date of this permission.

 

REASON: To comply with Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended).

 

2. The development hereby permitted shall be fully implemented in accordance with the following plans/documents (including any mitigation/enhancement recommended therein): 058-PL-050 Rev. D (Proposed Site Plan), 058-PL-100 Rev. C (Proposed Floor Plans), 058PL-200 Rev. C (Proposed Elevations), 058-PL-201 Rev. C (Proposed Elevations); Design and Access Statement (dated February 2021) produced by Black Architecture Ltd and Sustainability Commitment email dated 06.07.2021 from Nicola Dale.

 

REASON: To ensure that the development is carried out in accordance with the approved details and In the interest of proper planning.

 

3. The development hereby approved shall not be commenced until details of a site construction method statement and management plan shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority and shall include but not limited to the following:

i) Construction worker and visitor parking;

ii) anticipated number, frequency and size of construction vehicles;

iii) dust and Noise/Vibration mitigation measures;

iv) dust suppression measures;

v) Site security;

vi) vehicle manoeuvring and turning;

vii) locations for the loading/unloading and storage of plant, building materials and construction debris and contractors offices;

viii) procedures for on-site contractors to deal with complaints from local residents;

ix) measures to mitigate impacts on neighbouring highways; and

x) details of wheel water spraying facilities;

xi) Protection of pedestrian routes during construction Such details shall be fully implemented and retained for the duration of the works.

 

REASON: To protect the amenity of local residents, to ensure adequate highway and site safety in accordance with policies NBE11 and INF3 of the adopted Hart Local Plan - Strategy and Sites 2016-2032 and the NPPF 2019.

 

4. No development shall commence until a detailed surface water drainage scheme for the site, based on sustainable drainage principles has been submitted to an approved in writing by the local planning authority. The scheme shall be fully implemented in accordance with the approved details before first occupation of the development.

 

REASON: In the interest of managing surface water flooding and to satisfy policy NBE5 of the Adopted Hart Local Plan - Strategy and Sites 2016-2032 and the NPPF 2019.

 

5. No development shall raise above slab level, until details of all external materials for the building hereby approved are submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The details approved shall be fully implemented.

 

REASON: To ensure a high-quality external appearance of the buildings and to satisfy policy NBE9 of the adopted Hart Local Plan and Sites 2016-2032, saved local policy GEN1 of the Hart District Local Plan 1996-2006, policy  ...  view the full decision text for item 25.

Minutes:

Construction of a three-bedroom dwelling with associated car parking and hard/soft landscaping.

 

Councillor Blewett entered during this item.

 

Members considered the application and discussed the following:

           

·         The 1 metre gap between the proposal and No.8

·         Loss of light

·         Wheelie bin storage

·         Looking cramped

·         An additional car park space for No.8

·         Possibly converting the two small windows into one large window in the north facing kitchen/dining area to gain more light.

·         The use of air source heat pumps.

·         Installing PV panels at build to minimise costs.

·         Energy source type cannot be mandated.

·         The local plan policy has been followed.

 

Members voted for an amendment to proposal condition 2 and the addition of two Informatives in respect of PV Panels and window openings in 8 Crownfields which was carried.

 

DECISION - GRANTas per Officer recommendation with a change to condition 2 to include sustainability measures as detailed in the correspondence with the applicant and the addition of two Informatives.

 

CONDITIONS

 

1. The development hereby permitted shall be begun before the expiration of three years from the date of this permission.

 

REASON: To comply with Section 91 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended).

 

2. The development hereby permitted shall be fully implemented in accordance with the following plans/documents (including any mitigation/enhancement recommended therein): 058-PL-050 Rev. D (Proposed Site Plan), 058-PL-100 Rev. C (Proposed Floor Plans), 058PL-200 Rev. C (Proposed Elevations), 058-PL-201 Rev. C (Proposed Elevations); Design and Access Statement (dated February 2021) produced by Black Architecture Ltd and Sustainability Commitment email dated 06.07.2021 from Nicola Dale.

 

REASON: To ensure that the development is carried out in accordance with the approved details and In the interest of proper planning.

 

3. The development hereby approved shall not be commenced until details of a site construction method statement and management plan shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority and shall include but not limited to the following:

i) Construction worker and visitor parking;

ii) anticipated number, frequency and size of construction vehicles;

iii) dust and Noise/Vibration mitigation measures;

iv) dust suppression measures;

v) Site security;

vi) vehicle manoeuvring and turning;

vii) locations for the loading/unloading and storage of plant, building materials and construction debris and contractors offices;

viii) procedures for on-site contractors to deal with complaints from local residents;

ix) measures to mitigate impacts on neighbouring highways; and

x) details of wheel water spraying facilities;

xi) Protection of pedestrian routes during construction Such details shall be fully implemented and retained for the duration of the works.

 

REASON: To protect the amenity of local residents, to ensure adequate highway and site safety in accordance with policies NBE11 and INF3 of the adopted Hart Local Plan - Strategy and Sites 2016-2032 and the NPPF 2019.

 

4. No development shall commence until a detailed surface water drainage scheme for the site, based on sustainable drainage principles has been submitted to an approved in writing by the local planning authority. The scheme shall be fully implemented in accordance with  ...  view the full minutes text for item 25.

26.

20/02368/AMCON - LAND BETWEEN MOULSHAM LANE AND BROOME CLOSE, YATELEY pdf icon PDF 247 KB

Decision:

Variation of Condition 2 attached to Planning Permission 17/02793/REM dated 05/04/2018 to allow the relocation of the proposed SANG car park.

 

DECISION - GRANTas per Officer recommendation, with the addition of an informative to review site levels before completion and an amendment to conditions 2 and 7 to review site planting and site levels.

 

CONDITIONS

 

1 The development shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans and documents: Drawing Numbers: 021708-BEL-TV-01 Rev E (Presentation Planning Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-02 Rev E (Supporting Planning Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-03 Rev D (Storey Height Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-04 Rev D (Tenure Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-05 Rev D (Unit Type Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-06 (Location Plan); 021708-BEL-TV-07 Rev D (Character Area Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-08 Rev D (Materials Layout); 021708-SS01 (Street Scene 01); 021708-SS02 (Street Scene 02); 021708-SS03 Rev A (Street Scene 03); 021708-SS04 (Street Scene 04); 021708-H323-B-E1 (Housetype H323 - Elevations); 021708-H323-B-E2 (Housetype H323 - Elevations); 021708-H323-B-P1 (Housetype H323 - Floor Plans); 021708-H323-B-E3 (Housetype H323 - Elevations); 021708- H323-B-P2 (Housetype H323 - Floor Plans); 021708-H324-B-E1 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-B-E2 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-B-E3 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-B-P1 (Housetype H324 - Floor Plans); 021708-H423-B-E1 (Housetype H423 - Elevations); 021708-H423-B-P1 (Housetype H423 - Floor Plans); 021708-H431-B-E1 (Housetype H431 - Elevations); 021708- H431-B-P1 (Housetype H431 - Floor Plans); 021708-H432-B-E1 (Housetype H432 - Elevations); 021708-H432-B-P1 (Housetype H432 - Floor Plans); 021708-H30-B-E1 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-B-E2 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-B-P1 (Housetype H30 - Floor Plans); 021708-H30-B-E3 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-B-P2 (Housetype H30 - Floor Plans); 021708-H323-V-E1 (Housetype H323 - Elevations); 021708-H323-V-P1 (Housetype H323 - Floor Plans); 021708-H324-V-E1 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-V-E2 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-V-P1 (Housetype H324 - Floor Plans); 021708-H324-V-E3 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-V-P2 (Housetype H324 - Floor Plans); 021708-H424-V-E1 (Housetype H424 - Elevations); 021708- H424-V-P1 (Housetype H424 - Floor Plans); 021708-H431-V-E1 (Housetype H431 - Elevations); 021708-H431-V-E2 (Housetype H431 - Elevations); 021708-H431- V-P1 (Housetype H431 - Floor Plans); 021708-H20-V-E1 (Housetype H20 - Elevations); 021708-H20-V-P1 (Housetype H20 - Floor Plans); 021708-H30-V-E1 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-V-P1 (Housetype H30 - Floor Plans); 021708-H30-VE2 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-V-P2 (Housetype H30 - Floor Plans); 021708-3BH-V-E1 (Housetype 3BH - Elevations); 021708-3BH-VP1 (Housetype 3BH- Floor Plans); 021708-B1-V-E1 (Apartment Block 1 - Elevations); 021708-B1-VE2 (Apartment Block 1 - Elevations); 021708-B1-V-P1 (Apartment Block 1 - Ground Floor Plan); 021708-B1-V-P2 (Apartment Block 1 - First Floor Plan); 021708-B1-V-P3 (Apartment Block 1 - Second Floor Plan); 021708-B2-V-E1 (Apartment Block 2 - Elevations); 021708-B2-V-E2 (Apartment Block 2 - Elevations); 021708-B2-V-P1 (Apartment Block 2 - Ground Floor Plan); 021708-B2-V-P2 (Apartment Block 2 - First Floor Plan); 021708-B2-V-P3 (Apartment Block 2 - Second Floor Plan); 021708- H222-W-E1 (Housetype H222 - Elevations); 021708-H222-W-P1 (Housetype H222 - Floor Plans); 021708-H322-W-E1 (Housetype H322 - Elevations); 021708-H322- WP1 (Housetype H322 - Floor Plans); 021708-H323-W-E1 (Housetype H323 -  ...  view the full decision text for item 26.

Minutes:

Variation of Condition 2 attached to Planning Permission 17/02793/REM dated 05/04/2018 to allow the relocation of the proposed SANG car park.

 

Councillor Quarterman left the meeting for the duration of this item.

 

Members considered the application and discussed the following:

·         Loss of privacy and overlooking to residential properties

·         Noise disturbance

·         Reducing the ground level in the car park and circular walk to agreed levels

·         Providing adequate screening to car park and foot path

·         Superfast broadband as a requirement

 

It was suggested that officers and members visit the site with Bellway to gain agreement on the levels ideally before the sub soil and topsoil is added to provide reassurance to members.

 

It was also suggested local members meet with Bellway to discuss landscaping and privacy enhancements for residents.

 

Members voted for an amendment to proposal conditions 2 and 7 which was carried.

 

DECISION - GRANTas per Officer recommendation, with the addition of an informative to review site levels before completion and an amendment to conditions 2 and 7 to review site planting and site levels.

 

CONDITIONS

 

1 The development shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans and documents: Drawing Numbers: 021708-BEL-TV-01 Rev E (Presentation Planning Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-02 Rev E (Supporting Planning Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-03 Rev D (Storey Height Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-04 Rev D (Tenure Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-05 Rev D (Unit Type Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-06 (Location Plan); 021708-BEL-TV-07 Rev D (Character Area Layout); 021708-BEL-TV-08 Rev D (Materials Layout); 021708-SS01 (Street Scene 01); 021708-SS02 (Street Scene 02); 021708-SS03 Rev A (Street Scene 03); 021708-SS04 (Street Scene 04); 021708-H323-B-E1 (Housetype H323 - Elevations); 021708-H323-B-E2 (Housetype H323 - Elevations); 021708-H323-B-P1 (Housetype H323 - Floor Plans); 021708-H323-B-E3 (Housetype H323 - Elevations); 021708- H323-B-P2 (Housetype H323 - Floor Plans); 021708-H324-B-E1 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-B-E2 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-B-E3 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-B-P1 (Housetype H324 - Floor Plans); 021708-H423-B-E1 (Housetype H423 - Elevations); 021708-H423-B-P1 (Housetype H423 - Floor Plans); 021708-H431-B-E1 (Housetype H431 - Elevations); 021708- H431-B-P1 (Housetype H431 - Floor Plans); 021708-H432-B-E1 (Housetype H432 - Elevations); 021708-H432-B-P1 (Housetype H432 - Floor Plans); 021708-H30-B-E1 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-B-E2 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-B-P1 (Housetype H30 - Floor Plans); 021708-H30-B-E3 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-B-P2 (Housetype H30 - Floor Plans); 021708-H323-V-E1 (Housetype H323 - Elevations); 021708-H323-V-P1 (Housetype H323 - Floor Plans); 021708-H324-V-E1 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-V-E2 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-V-P1 (Housetype H324 - Floor Plans); 021708-H324-V-E3 (Housetype H324 - Elevations); 021708-H324-V-P2 (Housetype H324 - Floor Plans); 021708-H424-V-E1 (Housetype H424 - Elevations); 021708- H424-V-P1 (Housetype H424 - Floor Plans); 021708-H431-V-E1 (Housetype H431 - Elevations); 021708-H431-V-E2 (Housetype H431 - Elevations); 021708-H431- V-P1 (Housetype H431 - Floor Plans); 021708-H20-V-E1 (Housetype H20 - Elevations); 021708-H20-V-P1 (Housetype H20 - Floor Plans); 021708-H30-V-E1 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-V-P1 (Housetype H30 - Floor Plans); 021708-H30-VE2 (Housetype H30 - Elevations); 021708-H30-V-P2 (Housetype H30 - Floor Plans); 021708-3BH-V-E1 (Housetype 3BH - Elevations); 021708-3BH-VP1 (Housetype 3BH- Floor Plans); 021708-B1-V-E1 (Apartment Block 1 - Elevations); 021708-B1-VE2 (Apartment Block 1 - Elevations); 021708-B1-V-P1 (Apartment Block 1 - Ground Floor Plan); 021708-B1-V-P2 (Apartment Block 1 -  ...  view the full minutes text for item 26.

27.

21/01336/HOU - 66 FERNDALE ROAD, CHURCH CROOKHAM, FLEET pdf icon PDF 263 KB

Decision:

Conversion of loft to habitable accommodation to include the erection of one dormer window to front, one dormer window to side and one dormer window to rear.

DECISION – GRANT as per Officer recommendation.

Minutes:

Conversion of loft to habitable accommodation to include the erection of one dormer window to front, one dormer window to side and one dormer window to rear.

This application was reported to the planning committee for consideration because a Hart District Officer is the applicant.

 

Members considered the application.

 

DECISION – GRANT as per Officer recommendation.